top of page

When Payments Become a Utility, What is Left for the Bank?

4 hours ago
4 min read
When Payments Become a Utility, What is Left for the Bank?

An interview with Diederik Bruggink by Sean Murphy


A Spanish customer opens a Bizum wallet while travelling to the Baltic states, where no comparable private scheme exists, and pays in a shop. On the customer's screen it looks like a Bizum transaction; for the merchant, it arrives as a digital euro payment. Neither of them sees the link between the two systems. This is the scenario Diederik Bruggink uses to explain what European payments need to achieve.


Bruggink is Senior Director of Payments, Digital Finance and Innovation at WSBI-ESBG, the Brussels secretariat of two associations. ESBG, the European Savings and Retail Banking Group, speaks for 859 savings and retail banks in 27 countries, which by the association’s figures serve 163 million European clients. Its sister body, the World Savings and Retail Banking Institute, has 99 members in 76 countries.


Most ESBG members run on the traditional banking model, taking deposits from the public and lending them out to finance the economy, and his remit covers the payment and digital finance related issues that touch it, from the digital euro to the Payment Services Regulation, PSD3, the open finance framework, artificial intelligence and cybersecurity.


Of everything on that list, the digital euro could have the greatest effect on how ESBG members conduct business. The draft legislations recognise banks as the primary distributors of the digital euro and the main interface with customers. Members support its goals - preserving European monetary sovereignty and providing a digital form of cash - but Bruggink warns that making the digital euro legal tender will not on its own persuade consumers or merchants to use it. The proposition must also be useful and attractive in practice.


A main concern for savings banks is the holding limit. Deposits fund their lending, and Bruggink explains that every euro converted into digital euro is one euro less on a bank's balance sheet. If the limit is set too high, deposit outflows could weaken the balance sheet activity that savings banks earn their money from. ESBG have therefore argued for a low limit, consistent with treating the digital euro as a retail payment instrument rather than an account for holding money. The political debate has shifted towards governance: who should set the limit and through what process? A working document reported by MLex at the end of September pointed to common ground on limits set by the ECB beneath an overall ceiling, capped fees for merchants and between providers capped, and generally free basic services for consumers.


Another key concern is compensation. Basic services will be free for consumers, and merchants will be protected from overcharging, leaving the inter-PSP fee, a mechanism resembling interchange, as the only revenue a distributing bank can expect.


Bruggink's questions concern both the level of that fee and the activities it covers. He argues that it should recognise every stage of a digital euro transaction, including funding and defunding. In an open-funding scenario, for example, a customer could hold a digital euro wallet with a non-bank provider such as PayPal or Apple Pay. The customer bank would still move funds between the bank account and that wallet through the waterfall and the reverse waterfall mechanisms, yet, the inter-PSP fee would go to the wallet provider. Unless the fee structure also compensates funding and defunding, the savings bank would perform part of the service without being fairly compensated for it.


Private-sector schemes form the other part of this picture. In February, EPI, the company behind the Wero wallet, signed a memorandum of understanding with Bancomat, Bizum, SIBS MB WAY and Vipps MobilePay to interlink their solutions. Together, they cover around 130 million users in 13 countries, with cross-border person-to-person payments due this year and e-commerce and point-of-sale payments in 2027.


Bruggink regards these as European solutions and therefore relevant to the sovereignty agenda, but their coverage remains incomplete. Most are domestic, while EPI and Wero cover a region centred on France, Germany and the Benelux, with some Austrian banks expected to join. Pan-European coverage is not there yet, and how interoperability will work remains an open question. Some markets have no such scheme at all. Smaller countries also have limited budgets to invest in new payment solutions, and may invest only once, in either the digital euro or a private initiative, but probably not both. For that reason, he says, it is essential that the private initiatives and the digital euro "coexist and complement each other rather than compete with each other".


Customers, in Bruggink's view, should not have to care whether a payment uses private or public money, a distinction he thinks is already very hard to explain. "At the end of the day, customers just want to pay and as easy as possible," he says.


By 2030, Bruggink expects payments to be instant, seamless, where possible settled immediately across the EU, with commercial bank deposits, the digital euro, crypto-assets and tokenised deposits coexisting.


If the transaction itself becomes invisible, the banks value must lie elsewhere. Bruggink argues that banks must should remain trusted advisers and as the entry point to the financial system: onboarding customers, preventing fraud, supporting financial inclusion and helping people make payment and other financial choices.


Technology may change the form money takes, he says, but trust will remain the foundation. Local banks are best placed to turn innovation into something customers can understand and use.


To describe the experience he envisions, Bruggink reaches for mobile phones. A Deutsche Telekom customer travelling to Belgium does not look for an antenna with a Deutsche Telekom sticker on it; the phone simply works, while the operators settle between themselves in the background. Payments, in his view, could be heading the same way. "It's becoming a utility, rather than a premium product," he says, and utilities are difficult to charge a premium for and noticed only when they fail. That leaves banks with a demanding role: providing a trusted, reliable service whose complexity remains invisible to the customer.


The Spanish shopper paying in a Baltic store is the test of that utility; the fee arrangements now being negotiated in Brussels will determine whether the banks expected to provide it can make it pay.


 
 
bottom of page